Resource Adequacy History

• Principal Resource Adequacy Decision 

R.19-11-009

January 8, 2021 Track 3.B.2 Forward Energy Requirements Workshop

• Agenda
• Slides
• Workshop Recording

August 13, 2020 LCR Working Group

• Energy Division Presentation

November 18, 2020 Track 3.B Workshop - Day 1

• Agenda
• Presentations
  • Track 3.B Workshop: RA Structural Changes
  • GPI Proposal
• Q&A History
• Workshop Recording

November 23, 2020 Track 3.B Workshop - Day 2

• Presentation
• Agenda
• Q&A History
• Workshop Recording

November 24, 2020 BTM Workshop

• Presentation
• Agenda
• Q&A and Chat History
• Fact Sheet
• Workshop Recording

R.17-09-020

November 1, 2019 Central Procurement Entity Workshop

• Agenda
• Presentation
  • Proposed Settlement
    • Settlement Parties 
  • Other CPE Proposals
    • Energy Division
    • SCE
    • PG&E  
  • New Models for Resource Adequacy
    • Energy Division
    • Frank Wolak, Stanford

 September 5-6, 2019 RA Working Groups

• Agenda
• Presentations
  • RA Market Power and System Waivers
    • Energy Division  
  • QC for Hydro
    • Energy Division
    • PG&E 
  • EFC for Storage
    • Energy Division  
  • LCR Requirements
    • PG&E  
  • QC for Hybrid Resources
    • Energy Division
    • CESA
    • CAISO
    • SCE  
  • ELCC
    • SCE
    • Energy Division

 March 12 and 13, 2019 - Track 3 Workshop

• Agenda
• Presentations
  • Energy Division
    • Load Forecasting
    • Path 26
    • Waivers
    • ELCC  
  • California Energy Commission
  • AReM
  • CAISO
  • CalCCA
  • CEERT
  • CESA
  • Joint DR Parties
  • PG&E
  • SCE
    • Demand Response QC
    • Flex Attribute Unbundling
    • NQC for Storage Combined with Another Technology
    • Path 26 Constraint
    • Resource Adequacy Load Forecast
    • Waiver Process for System and Flaxible  
  • SDG&E
  • Sunrun

March 4, 2019 - Energy Division Track 3 Proposals

• Energy Division Staff Proposals

 July 19, 2018 - Multi-year/Single Buyer Workshop

• Agenda
• Workshop Audio Recording
• Matrix of Proposals
• Presentations
  • Energy Division
  • Calpine
  • PG&E
  • CalCCA
  • IEP
  • SDG&E
  • NRG
  • WPTF
  • CAISO
  • AReM
  • Shell  

July 12, 2018 - Energy Division Track 2 Proposals

• Staff Proposal on Multi-year RA Requirements
• Staff Proposal on Transparency

 February 16, 2018 - Energy Division Track 1 Staff Proposals

• Current Trends in California's Resource Adequacy Program 
  • Updated April 27, 2018 to ensure the full legend in Figure 3 is visible
• Staff Proposal on RA Measurement Hours
• Staff Proposal on LSE Participation

February 22-23, 2018 - Phase 1 Proposal Workshop

• Agenda

Multi-year Requirement/Centralized Local Capacity Procurement/RA Reform

• Energy Division
• ORA
• PG&E
• Peninsula Clean Energy
• AReM
• IEP
• WPTF
• Middle River Power

Options for Treatment of Late LCR/FCR Studies and Alignment of CPUC RA Hours and CAISO Availability Assessment Hours

• Energy Division
• SCE
• CAISO

 ELCC Enhancements

• SCE
• WPTF

 Preferred RFOs

• CEERT

 Flexible RA

• Cogentrix
• Wellhead

 CCA Load Migration 

• Sonoma Clean Power
• Joint CCAs
• SCE
• PG&E  

Local Counting for Demand Response/Use Limited Resources

• CAISO

System Load Forecast Variability

• CAISO
• Calpine

November 7, 2017 - Working group on Weather Sensitive Demand Response, Behind-the-Meter Resources and Comments on the R.17-09-020 OIR

• Agenda
• Presentations
  • Energy Division
  • SDG&E
  • CAISO

October 23, 2017 - Working Group on Path 26, Dispatchability, and Seasonal Local Requirements

• Presentation
  • Energy Division
  • CAISO

 R.14-10-010

February 14, 2017 - Phase 3 Proposals Workshop Day 2

• Agenda
• Presentations
  • ELCC
    • Energy Division
    • Calpine
    • E3 Supplemental Presentation on Planning Standards
    • SCE
  • Load Forecast Proposals
    • CLECA
    • Energy Division
      • PG&E
      • SDG&E
      • SCE
    • PG&E

February 7, 2017 - Phase 3 Proposals Workshop Day 1

• Agenda
• Presentations
  • Flexible Capacity
    • SCE
    • PG&E
    • Powerex
    • CESA
    • Cogentrix
  • Demand Response & Storage
    • SDG&E
    • SCE
    • SCE (2 hr. product)
  • Implementation
    • CPUC
    • PG&E

December 22, 2016

• Draft Staff Working Paper: An Assessment of Capacity Under Contract

December 16, 2016 - Energy Division Staff Proposals

• Monthly LOLE and ELCC Proposal
• Other Staff Proposals

November 9, 2016 - Workshop on Flexible Resource Adequacy

• Agenda
• Presentations
  • CPUC
  • CAISO DMM
  • SCE
  • CAISO
  • PG&E
  • CPUC

November 8, 2016 - Workshop on ELCC Methodology

• Agenda
• Presentations
  • CPUC
  • Calpine
  • SCE
  • CPUC

October 27, 2016 - Workshop on Load Forecast Adjustment Methodology

• Revised Load forecast Adjustment Methodology Paper
• Agenda
• Presentations
  • CPUC
  • CEC
  • CLECA
  • PG&E  
  • SCE

April 5, 2016 - Workshop on Flexible Resource Adequacy

• Workshop Report
• Agenda
• Presentations
  • CPUC Staff Presentations   
  • Session 1:  CAISO and SCE Presentations
  • Session 2:  Presentations
  • Session 3:  Presentations
  • Session 4:  Presentations
  • Session 5:  Presentations

March 25, 2016 -  Energy Division Revised RA Proposals

• Revised Locational and Monthly ELCC/RA Obligations Proposal
• Revised RA Capacity Value for DR Resources

March 24, 2016 - Load Forecast Adjustment Webinar

• Revised CEC Load Forecast Adjustment Presentation

February 18, 2016 - Workshop:

• Agenda
• Presentations
  • CEC Load Forecast Development
  • CPUC ED ELCC and RA obligations  
  • CAISO RA Presentation
  • Combined CPUC-joint DR Parties 20 DR workshop proposals
  • PG&E RA Proposals
  • SCE Local DR for Local RA Presentation
  • SCE Net Load Peak ELCC

February 9, 2015 - Workshop:

• Agenda
• Energy Staff Presentation  
• Party Presentations
• AReM
• CAISO
• CEC
• CESA
• Calpine
• MCE Clean Energy
• PG&E
• SCE  
• SDG&E

January 6, 2015: Energy Division releases Staff Proposal as part of the Resource Adequacy Proceeding - RA Program Refinements.

Previous Rulings:

• R. 11-10-023
• R. 09-10-032
• R. 08-01-025
• R. 05-12-013
• R. 04-04-003