The California Public Utilities Commission opened this proceeding through an Order Instituting Rulemaking (OIR) adopted on July 16, 2020. It will build on requirements for the utility risk assessment and mitigation framework adopted in the first Safety Model Assessment Proceeding (S-MAP), A. 15-05-002 et al, and in R.13-11-006, the Risk-Based Decision-Making proceeding.

 

Scoping Ruling

Phase I

·    Track 1: Clarifying Risk Decision Framework (RDF) Technical Requirements 

o   Track 1 will consider whether there are discrete technical questions regarding the RDF that the Commission should clarify in the short term (larger, more substantive revisions to the RDF will be considered in Phase II).

 

August 18, 2021 Technical Working Group

         Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         Master Slide Presentation

 

July 28, 2021 Technical Working Group

         Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         Joint IOU's Slide Presentation

         CalAdvocates' Slide Presentation

 

July 16, 2021 Technical Working Group

         Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         SPD's Slide Presentation

   Joint IOU's Slide Presentation

   Cal Advocates' Slide Presentation

   MGRA's Slide Presentation

   

June 22, 2021 Technical Working Group

         Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         SPD's Slide Presentation

   PG&E's Slide Presentation

   SCE's Slide Presentation

 

May 6, 2021 Technical Working Group

         Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         Master Slide Presentation

 

April 14, 2021 Technical Working Sub-Group

         Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         PG&E's Slide Presentation

   PG&E's Illustrative Example

 

March 10, 2021 Technical Working Group

         Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         Master Slide Presentation

 

February 3, 2021 Technical Working Group

         Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         Master Slide Presentation

 

December 15, 2020 Workshop

·         Agenda

·         Workshop Recording

·         Master Slide Presentation

  

Track 2: Safety and Operational Metrics 

o   Track 2 will consider safety and operational performance metrics and their application broadly. This work will include refining metrics adopted in D.19-04-020 and developing new metrics as needed. Work on metrics will address D.20-05-053, which approved PG&E’s reorganization plan and directed the development of safety and operational metrics for PG&E linked to an Enhanced Oversight and Enforcement Process. 

 

August 19, 2021 Technical Working Group

         Workshop Recording  

         Revised Safety Performance Metrics 

 

May 4, 2021 Technical Working Group

         Agenda

         Workshop Recording  

         Master Slide Presentation  

         Secondary Master Table Slide Presentation         

April 1, 2021 Technical Working Group

         Agenda

         Master Slide Presentation

 

January 28, 2021 Workshop

          Agenda

          Workshop Recording

          Master Slide Presentation 

 

·    Track 3: Refining RAMP and Related Procedural Requirements

o   Track 3 will focus on whether there are RAMP, general rate case (GRC) and Risk Spending Accountability Reports (RSAR) procedural or definitional requirements that the Commission should refine or clarify.

February 9, 2021 Workshop  

           Agenda

           Workshop Recording

           Master Slide Presentation

 

·     Track 4: Small and Multi-Jurisdictional Utilities (SMJUs) 

o   Track 4 will consider questions unique to the SMJUs - To occur at a future date

         Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         Master Slide Presentation

Phase II

The issues to be determined in Phase II of this proceeding will be revisited at the conclusion of Phase I and may be further outlined in a second Scoping Memo. The issues to be considered will broadly include refining the RDF, considering a risk tolerance standard, and developing next steps.

Workshop #2 June 29, 2022 Technical Working Group Safety Policy Division (SPD) staff will present an initial draft set of Staff Proposal recommendations to the parties regarding the Phase II subset of issues in (R.)20-07-13.

       Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         Master Slide Presentation

 

TWG #4 June 16, 2022 Technical Working Group Presentation and Discussion where parties will develop the details of implementation for the Level 4 Recommendation identified as “Risk Modeling 3,” and parties will discuss the following scoping memo question: “Should the Commission consider impacts on environmental and social justice communities, including the extent to which action in this proceeding impacts the achievement of any of the nine goals of the Commission’s Environmental and Social Justice (ESJ) Action Plan?”

       Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         Master Slide Presentation

 

TWG #3 June 2, 2022 Technical Working Group Presentation and Discussion to develop the details of implementation of Level 4 Recommendation identified as "MAVF 3"

     Agenda

         Workshop Recording

         Master Slide Presentation

 

TWG #2 May 20, 2022 Technical Working Group Presentation and Discussion to develop the details of implementation of Level 4 Recommendation identified as "MAVF 2"

     Agenda

         Workshop Recording  

         Master Slide Presentation

 

TWG #1 April 20, 2022 Technical Working Group Presentation and Discussion of Level 4 IOU Baseline Assessment Revised Recommendations

     Agenda

         Workshop Recording  

         Master Slide Presentation

     Level 4 Recommendations Report

 

Workshop #1 - March 3, 2022 - Presentation of the Level 4 IOU Baseline Assessment

Workshop Agenda

Workshop Slides

Workshop Recording

   Risk Spend Efficiency Assessment - IOU Baseline Assessment

 Workshop Model:  Risk Spend Efficiency Model

 Workshop Model:  Randarray

 Workshop Model:  Dynamic Array RSE

 Workshop Model:  RSE Multiple Libraries

 Workshop Model:  Filtered Risk Rollup

 Workshop Model:  Wheels of Misfortune